clifton seeney wrote:
Monsieur with out the Corps commanders or Div commanders in this there is no clear chain of command. I don't command any thing but me and I was told I don't command even me I have a Div commander over me and a Corps commander over him and a Army commander over all. With out the chain of command all who play are their own commanders and not under orders from any but themselves this might be a can of worms but some in the club would have it this way I don't have the rank to command my Brig so if a Brig commander steps up I will step down.
Col Dumas, as to your comments, the official chain of command only applies to official club business, and to a tournament where the rules of engagement are concerned with specific command organizations, such as a
Div or Brig Challenge that specifies the teams be from official unit formations.
However, in situations such as the topic under discussion, there should be room to allow for teams of players to be formed (such as your III Corps Artillery Brigade, and my own
Tirailleurs et Dragons! ) which have been formed originally because there was no official LGA Div or Brig combat teams.
Prince Repnin is referencing this tourney as a Divisional Tournament, but the fact remains that there are not necessarily the commanding officers willing to lead or participate in this kind of event, hence we have what I like to refer to as
provisional battle Brigades, etc, like your's and mine.
There are no club rules governing for example if you choose to lead a team of players in a game against a team of players from another army that restrict who is in command. These are games taken on by the players themselves, and they can decide who is in command, etc.
Regards,