This system is designed for discussion, to get to know others. The weaker players might learn something, the stronger ones as well I should think.
This method is not designed to be historical and there are many other systems out there. This is to enjoy some camaraderie. The only real person in charge is the person doing the turns.
The main goal is to have fun. Some will observe, some will add banter; others will have very good points.
The Point man is the player. He does not have to listen to others he can play the turn as he sees fit.
If you join with the idea that you are part of a group discussion and that the pointer plays the turns as he wants regardless of your input. I would assume that typically the point man would want to play and do well and listen to others to an extent. I think the point man should be someone of moderate competence. A rank beginner may find it difficult. Although in context of training that would be excellent.
I hope this clears it up.
I am ready to setup private discussion boards for the teams whenever if ever some games are started.
New forum created to support the system.
http://www.wargame.ch/board/nwc2/default.asp
Colonel Pierre D.
Armee du Rhin
VII Corps, 22eme Division, 1ere Brigade
http://www.wargame.ch/board/nwc2/default.asp